Reporter Defends 'Nail in the Coffin' Comment at Sydney Trial

Investigative journalist Kate McClymont told the Downing Centre local court on Tuesday that a phrase she used during a recorded phone call described the strength of her evidence, not the fate of the accused. The Sydney Morning Herald chief investigative reporter was the third witness called by the defence in the trial of former media executive Alan Jones. She was cross-examined by defence barrister Gabrielle Bashir SC.

The court heard a recording of a conversation between McClymont and the mother of complainant A, the mother of Jones's youngest alleged victim. During the call, McClymont called new information a nail in the coffin. Bashir pressed the witness to say the comment targeted Jones personally. McClymont rejected that reading. She stated the phrase applied to the story she was developing after learning the boy had spoken to police during the year of the alleged assault.

McClymont explained that police had informed her in December 2023, after her initial investigation was published, that they had received no complaints against Jones and had not investigated him. The mother's account that her son had previously been questioned by officers in his school principal's office provided a new angle for the reporter. The court heard that McClymont was later connected with the detective who had spoken to the teenager.

Bashir also questioned the reporter about text messages sent to the mother. One message indicated that the NSW police minister's office and the sex crimes unit had told the family her son would remain unidentified if the case reopened because he was under 18. Another message expressed hope that Jones would face consequences for his actions. The reporter acknowledged sending that text, which included two poo emojis.

McClymont confirmed she sent an enthusiastic message to a police media contact when Jones's arrest was expected. On the day police took him into custody at his Circular Quay apartment, she contacted the same person to verify details. She responded positively once the arrest was confirmed.

Jones faces 21 charges of sexual touching and indecent assault. Five men allege they were assaulted or sexually touched by him between 2003 and 2020. In testimony last month, complainant A said Jones put his tongue in his mouth and touched his bottom during an overnight stay at the former 2GB broadcaster's Fitzroy Falls farm. A began corresponding with Jones at age 13. Jones has denied all charges.

The trial continues before judge Glenn Walsh. McClymont said she gave a statement to police in June 2024 but continued reporting until she was told she would testify for the prosecution. She is scheduled to appear in court again on Thursday.